Biloxi: 228-435-3000 | Ocean Springs: 228-872-6000 | Hattiesburg: 601-583-5000
He Promised To Hold The Ladder, Then Took A Phone Call
A city worker promised to hold a roofer's ladder, then walked off to take a phone call and let him fall. A judge blamed the roofer. Here is how a ladder fall injury Mississippi case turns on a broken promise, not an obvious danger.
The TV lawyer on the billboard will look at a ladder fall injury Mississippi case and quit before he starts, because the man was an experienced roofer who knew a wet roof is dangerous. The billboard lawyer hears independent contractor and open and obvious and folds the file, because he has never separated the obvious danger from the real cause of the fall. He hands it to a secretary who tells you there is no case. There was a case. The Pegues family proved it on appeal.
Fredrick Pegues was a fifty seven year old roofer asked to climb up and measure a gymnasium roof for the city. He did not want to climb. A city employee pushed him to go up and promised, more than once, that he would hold the ladder. I will not let you fall, the worker said, and braced the ladder with a chair. Near the top, the worker’s phone rang. He walked off to take the call and forgot he was holding the ladder. It fell. Pegues fell with it, breaking his shoulder, his ankle, and his hip.
Why A Ladder Fall Injury Mississippi Defendant Thinks It Cannot Lose
The city ran straight to two statutes. One says a property owner is not liable when an independent contractor is hurt by a danger he knew or should have known about. The other shields a government from failing to warn about a danger that is open and obvious. The trial judge bought it and threw the case out, reasoning that an experienced roofer obviously knew a ladder can slip on a wet roof. For a badly injured man that looked like the end.
It was not the end, because the city argued the wrong danger. A ladder fall injury Mississippi court looks at what actually caused the fall, not the general risk floating around the job site. Pegues was not hurt because a roof was wet. He was hurt because a man promised to hold his ladder and then walked away. The Court of Appeals reversed and sent the case back for a jury. The open and obvious shield only covers a failure to warn. It does not cover a government employee who creates the danger through his own careless act.
A Promise You Rely On Becomes A Duty
Here is the part the billboard lawyer never understood. When that worker promised to hold the ladder, and Pegues climbed because he trusted that promise, the promise became a legal duty. Walking away and breaking it was plain negligence, the garden variety kind, and no statute about obvious dangers wipes that out. This was never really a case about a wet roof or a slippery condition on the property. It was a case about a man who said I have got you and then did the opposite. A secretary at a billboard firm reads independent contractor and stops reading. A real lawyer reads the whole thing and finds the duty.
A ladder fall injury Mississippi claim against a government also runs on strict notice deadlines under the Tort Claims Act. Miss the notice window and even a strong case dies before a court ever weighs the promise that was broken.
Before You Trust Anyone With This, Get My Free Book
I wrote a free book that shows you how these cases really work and the quiet mistakes that destroy them. Read it before you let a billboard lawyer’s secretary decide your fall was your own fault.
Get My Free Book Before You Talk To Any Insurance Company
If you were hurt on a job because someone promised to keep you safe and then failed, do not let an open and obvious excuse end it. Learn how a serious Mississippi work injury lawyer separates the obvious risk from the real cause of the fall.
P.S. The Pegues decision is public record at the Mississippi Court of Appeals, No. 2024-CA-01085-COA. A judge threw the case out and the appeals court reinstated it, because a broken promise to hold a ladder is negligence no obvious danger statute can hide.